Decorily's latest activity

I guess the ball is the offside line as per the law quoted by you so theoretically the 9 could move away from the scrum on that line...

If you are the referee then you are the sole judge of fact and your interpretation of law is final!!

Welcome. Rugby is a game for all shapes and sizes. The laws of the game apply equally to all.

Thanks

What problems arose?

Do something about the current CBS sequence also and remove the need for a 'gap' on bind!

Yes and in this case it appears that the offender was penalised twice for a single act of foul play.

How did this ref see it differently?

we'll have to agree to disagree on the nuances of that. Because - for me - what if his hands were out but the ball still 1m away. I'm...

Surely a player can only be defined as 'attempting to control the ball' after having touched it.

despite the thread's title :-)

Juggling is still deemed to be in possession and 'tackleable'!

Yes it was a tackle without ball as far as I'm aware. Referee deemed it early before the ball was touched/played. If he had been '...

Video?

Maybe it's simply a case of referee couldn't possibly make an on field decision ( other than the default!) and so left the TMO the...