jdeagro's latest activity

I do think there's some merit in having a different protocol for TJs, who have a stake in the game and opposing goals, vs ARs who have...

I think the ref got this one wrong too, IMO. Red BC should've been penalized, if any penalty was coming from this. He jumped forward and...

in a parallel universe BC dives defender stands up, not fully aware of BC diving forwards BC collides with D CF Biggar v Russell .

In the original video, it didn't happen, but your post I replied to made it sound like what can happen is binary. So I'm presenting a...

What if the ball carrier started diving and then a defender disengaged from the ruck without realizing and the players collided with...

I agree... how would this have played out if a defender from the ruck had stood up while he was diving over, resulting in contact in the...

I disagree, just because there was no contact doesn't mean there wasn't any danger. I’d say all the players in the ruck were in danger.

You could, of course, give a FK for forming a tunnel >1m wide. Personally, I would prefer to use game management rather than award a FK...

I'll respond to your hypothetical with a hypothetical, would you not card a player who took a swing at another player, if his punch...

They can jump across the line of touch in certain circumstances, but they can't be thrown across. 18.31 Players jumping for the ball...

I have had this but I now make it clear in the PMB that I will give the defensive mark and it is up to the attack to form the 1m gap...

Certainly legal, and creative. 🙂

I think this is a sensible law amendment. Overall, I'm torn though. I love the field awareness and in-the-moment decision making that...

in England the current Law Variations adopted by the RFU do make this explicitly illegal 9.11.(a) Players must not do anything that is...

This seems fair to me except the wider the tunnel the more leeway the throwing team has to throw the ball "straight". Doubtful a team...