Search results

  1. menace

    Hands in the ruck?

    Looking at the ruck at 4:05 (video time) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmdKqbe3m20 Is anyone awarding that try? Surely the player that picks up the ball is part of the ruck? (he's not last feet/man). Although the other 2 behind him are not technically bound - I'd judge they have still...
  2. menace

    Weight/size grading - Australia attempt

    http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-union/union-news/rugby-launches-new-sizeforage-guidelines-and-concussion-blue-card-system-for-juniors-and-seniors-20180215-h0w4v1.html Interesting to see how this actually is applied. AU/ARU is historically crap at providing and training experts (with no money) so I...
  3. menace

    Simplified laws: kick to save a knock on resolved?

    I actually hate to drag this one up as it seems to cause much debate... *flashback* ie http://www.rugbyrefs.com/showthread.php?13721-knock-on-or-play-on-from-kick&highlight=knockon 1/3 believed that a BC"lost possession" ball that is kicked to be saved from a knock-on is a permitted kick -...
  4. menace

    Rwc nz v aus

    Ok...first shot. Actually I think it's pretty rank....but I still had to chuckle. Unfortunately I think NZ will be too good for Aust. They're in good form and just clinical all over the park.
  5. menace

    Ire vs fra - offside in general play when touched?

    Watching the ire vs fra rwc2015 and early in NO PKs France for offside when in front of last person who played the ball. On first sighting I had no issue (and still don't really) so I don't have an issue with the decision NO made at what he saw but it did make me wonder at what point is the...
  6. menace

    Grab tackle involving legs

    A comment from another thread that a legal tackle resulting in an injury is not a reason to card a player reminded me of this incident. It happend on the weekend where the tackled player suffered a compound fracture. See clip in here...
  7. menace

    [7's/10's] Heel kick conversion? Would you allow it?

    Would you allow this? http://www.foxsports.com.au/rugby/video-tom-pincus-kicks-incredible-backheel-conversion-at-darwin-sevens/story-e6frf4pu-1227201180122 Not sure if this is visible outside Oz, but it was a heel kick for a try conversion. Very clever, but do you think it is legal?
  8. menace

    Wales vs wallabies - CJs influence.

    I have a few queries about son of CJs decions, no doubt at the risk of being accused and lambasted of merely being a biased wallabies fan. Some I genuinely don't understand and some I'm trying to figure if perhaps I apply a wrong interpretation at grassroots level. All these times are on the...
  9. menace

    [7's/10's] Penalty goal in 7s - place kick allowed?

    I think I know the answer, but have got myself confused because of what appears to be a contradiction in the law book. Can you take a place kick for penalty goal in 7s? I've not ever seen it and I think the answer is no because of this 7's variation. 21.3 How the penalty and free kicks are...
  10. menace

    Excellent tackling technique...even for a soccer match!

    A few players could learn a thing from this fellow! Sign him up for the wallabies! http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=x5YD1nxBBkg
  11. menace

    Must have a receiver?! 2014 law book change

    No doubt we've all heard someone yell "They need to have a receiver, sir!" And of course we all said 'bollocks' in our heads as we play on. Call me slow but I've just realised the new 2014 law book has changed the wording of the receiver positioning law! From "Where the receiver must stand...
  12. menace

    Taken out in the air....

    Take a look at this... https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=733449993363042 Any thoughts? (Besides...ouch!) RC? YC? PK? Play on? (I was AR on far side to the action and had a good view of this and gave some input to the ref about it. What input would you give?) Player was knocked out and...
  13. menace

    Making the press for all the wrong reasons!

    I was a witness to this. http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rugby-union/canberra-rugby-union-player-alleged-to-have-headbutted-referee-and-kinghit-player-20140525-zrnku.html I won't say anymore on here until after the judiciary hearing, but the article is pretty accurate. The only thing to add...
  14. menace

    Not straight advantage....

    Had this in my game yesterday, I'm comfortable with my decision and wouldn't change it if it happened again but referee coach thinks I have it wrong... interested in how others might have handled it. Green lineout. I'm at the back of the lineout (I have an AR). It's a shockingly crooked long...
  15. menace

    Oz scrum management for 2014...

    This is the gist of what we've been told (James Leckie provided the presentation)...and of course no signal at all for the SH to feed. Anyone experiencing any issues with preseason trial games?
  16. menace

    Ben Mowen dumps Wallabies.....

    http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport/rugby/wallabies-captain-ben-mowen-may-struggle-to-secure-early-release-from-aru-ahead-of-france-move/story-fnii0ksb-1226798473755?from=public_rss I don't buy it. After finally breaking into the wallabies, being named captain (although inevitability just short...
  17. menace

    Possible Ashes contest?

    After Broad's dismantling of Aussies on day 1, Johnson is having his go and has carved up the poms to have them at 8-94 at tea! Could this be an Ashes series with some competition put up by the Aussies?? (Pieterson is still being a w@nker...so some things never change from Ashes to Ashes! He's...
  18. menace

    Garces the speed hump...

    http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0g7dLSyCZfs Gotta make you chuckle....a double shoulder charge for his troubles!
  19. menace

    AUS rugby really is in trouble....

    http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rugby-union/union-news/pay-cut-test-for-wallabies-20131016-2vmy8.html Not world breaking news about the financial issues facing the ARU....but it's not boding well for Australian rugby. Elite players will chase money elsewhere and other codes and leaving the...
  20. menace

    Oh Shhhiiiiiiiit!

    Take a look at this at the 2:45m mark... http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KTUJgYRz1WE When I saw this live I cringed and expected the worst - fortunately it seems he's OK (by some miracle!) Yes I know this is league, but I had no doubt in my mind what I would be giving if I saw this, even without...
Top