Search results

  1. C

    [Law] Ball in or out ruck ( england v tonga )

    1st half , about 20 something mins into game ( i didn't note time ) England have ball in ruck . Ref tells red to stay on side ( which they do ) . But england hind foot got legally exaggerated , by ref ??? England had 2 or 3 men forming their ruck & all on their feet . But they also had a...
  2. C

    [Law] Charge down & off side

    Red 10 kicks ball on his 10 meter line towards opposition . ( straight kick ) And does not advance forward after his kick . Red 6 is approx 1 meter in front of kicker & approx 5 meters to kickers right side . Red 7 is approx 2 meters in front of his kicker . White 10 charges down kick & red 7...
  3. C

    [Law] In goal

    Below is from app . ( in goal ) See bit in bold . Surely it makes no sense ? If this person with foot over dead ball line , picks up a ball From in , in goal , then surely he made it dead . Am i reading this wrong .. If any part of a defending player is in in-goal, that player is considered to...
  4. C

    [Tackle] Tap tackle , or actually no tackle

    Red 7 chasing blue 7 ball carrier . From behind. Red 7 cant quite catch blue 7 for a full on tackle, so dives and taps blue 7 ankle . They both end up on floor Blue 7 whilst on floor , turns on floor & presents ball for his support players. Who are too slow getting there. Red 7 gets...
  5. C

    [Tackle] Red card or not

    https://twitter.com/eirSport/status/1079076110502187008 Take a look at red card video ..
  6. C

    [Law] Well intended advice v correct answer

    Hi all . And a question to phil E . Many times on this rugby forum . A poster will post A question , and members some time offer good advice / wrong advice ( even if not intended to be wrong ) .. some times spot on advice & some times way off the wall advice . I understand the concept of a...
  7. C

    [Law] Ulster v scarlets kick to touch

    Ulster v scarlets today . Pro 14 competition . 33 mins on clock . Scarlets do a clearance kick from inside their 22 & ball caught by ulster . And im sure scarlets got throw in also .. Looks like a good clip to look at . Can somebody put it up ( i cant )
  8. C

    [Law] Red card or not

    http://www.punditarena.com/rugby/smcmahon/watch-sergio-parisse-saw-red-getting-tackled-perpignan/amp/
  9. C

    [Law] Charge down from kick from in goal & out side goal

    Scene 1 Defender takes ball back into his own in goal . Kicks ball from in goal & an attacking player who is in field of play ( just out side goal line )Charges ball down & ball goes dead over dead ball line . How would you restart game .. Scene 2 . Defender kicks ball , just out side his own...
  10. C

    [Law] Charge down from kick from in goal & out side goal

    Scene 1 Defender takes ball back into his own in goal . Kicks ball from in goal & an attacking player who is in field of play ( just out side goal line ) Charges ball down & ball goes dead over dead ball line . How would you restart game .. Scene 2 . Defender kicks ball , just out side his own...
  11. C

    [In-goal] Advantage from knock on into in goal

    Argentina v wales . 10 mins into game blue 15 attempts to catch a kick outside red try line . He fumbles catch & knocks ball on . The ball lands in red in goal & red 15 touches ball down & makes it dead . Red team ask ref ( jaco ) if they can have a 22 kick out . Ref says no ,,its your scrum at...
  12. C

    [Line out] Wales v argentina

    53 mins into game . Wales are awarded a line out . I watched hi lights only , & cant rewind & re watch . Blue have ball , run down side line . And blue ends up on floor , via tackle . Places ball back on floor , & then it looks like his arm or leg goes over touch line . He is touching ball the...
  13. C

    [Ruck] no more 1 man ruck ?? thoughts

    Clarification in Law by the Designated Members of Rugby Committee Clarification 2 – 2018 Union ARU Law Reference Law 15 – Amended Ruck Law (Trial from Jan, 2018) Date April 17, 2018 Request I refer to your recent correspondence with Rugby AU General Counsel Mr. Patrick Eyers regarding Rugby AU’s...
  14. C

    [Law] Will you stay or will you go

    Hi all . Just wondering all new referees started this season . Did you enjoy taking up the whistle . Were you satisfied or dissapointed with your mentoring . Did you find it harder than what you anticipated . Will you come back next season . ( im not looking for a point by point answer to...
  15. C

    [Law] Munster v toulon

    I didnt see try in todays match Heard that conor murray scored a try , following 5 min tmo debate . Can some body put it up , to see what it was all about . Thanks
  16. C

    [Law] Knock on from shoulder

    Scarlets playing munster . Munster just had a try disallowed from an obvious knock on from arm . ( approx 17 mins 1st half ) But raises an interesting question from commentator .who suggesyed ball came off a munster shoulder . It clearly hit munster arm between elbow to shoulder . But...
  17. C

    [Law] Not 10 sir

    Team red kick off to start match . Ball travels 8 meters with force ( will easily make 10 meters ) 2 possible scenarios . Scene 1 . Player from blue team has run after kick is taken in 2 meters from 10 meter line And the ball has bounced off his leg with force and gone into touch . . Scene...
  18. C

    [Law] What would you do

    I had a game last week . Which got me thinking about a similar situation . In my game approx 10 mins into game. Team a went to score a try , but grounding of ball was too tight for me to award try . As i genuinely couldnt tell was he also touching , the touch in goal line 1st . Straight away...
  19. C

    Eddie jones & england

    Will ed walk away after 6 nations or hang on for easy pay cheque .
  20. C

    [6N] Tmo farce

    https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/
Top