- Joined
- Jul 12, 2005
- Messages
- 13,680
- Post Likes
- 1,760
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 2
Proposal
8.1 “(a)” Add sentence (italics) a) The referee is the sole judge of when a team has gained an advantage. The referee has wide discretion when making decisions. The referee may consult with the team captain in deciding which the greater advantage to his team is.
The rationale can best be outlined by an example.
Reds v Blacks.
Red attack on Black 22, 5 metres from touch. Referee plays advantage to Red.
Play moves to mid-field/some forward progress. Black infringe again, no advantage possible, referee awards PK. Depending on the score/time, the most advantageous position for the PK may be at place of first infringement (kick to touch and line-out) OR at the place of the second infringement (kick at goal.)
It seems reasonable and positive for the referee to consult with the captain in such instances.
Justifcation
To introduce into law what has become common practice.
8.1 “(a)” Add sentence (italics) a) The referee is the sole judge of when a team has gained an advantage. The referee has wide discretion when making decisions. The referee may consult with the team captain in deciding which the greater advantage to his team is.
The rationale can best be outlined by an example.
Reds v Blacks.
Red attack on Black 22, 5 metres from touch. Referee plays advantage to Red.
Play moves to mid-field/some forward progress. Black infringe again, no advantage possible, referee awards PK. Depending on the score/time, the most advantageous position for the PK may be at place of first infringement (kick to touch and line-out) OR at the place of the second infringement (kick at goal.)
It seems reasonable and positive for the referee to consult with the captain in such instances.
Justifcation
To introduce into law what has become common practice.