Referee Rating - Craig Joubert - England v Scotland (RWC 2011)

[peperami]

BIASED REPORT Yes
OFFSIDES 9
ADVANTAGE 9
SCRUMS 9
RUCKS & MAULS 9
TACKLE 9
CONTROL 10
COMMUNICATION 10
DANGEROUS PLAY 8
FITNESS 9
ATTITUDE 10
OVERALL 9
OTHER COMMENTS Excellent display showed empathy to the players, clearly communicated his requirements and helped the game flow.

 

[andyscott]

Re: Referee Rating by peperami - Craig Joubert - England v Scotland (RWC 2011)

BIASED REPORT Yes
OFFSIDES 9
ADVANTAGE 9
SCRUMS 9
RUCKS & MAULS 9
TACKLE 9
CONTROL 10
COMMUNICATION 10
DANGEROUS PLAY 8
FITNESS 9
ATTITUDE 10
OVERALL 9
OTHER COMMENTS Excellent display showed empathy to the players, clearly communicated his requirements and helped the game flow.

I agree with most things, but did the game flow anywhere? (not refs fault)

 

[Ian_Cook]

Referee Rating by Ian_Cook - Craig Joubert - England v Scotland (RWC 2011)

BIASED REPORT No
OFFSIDES 10
ADVANTAGE 10
SCRUMS 8
RUCKS & MAULS 9
TACKLE 9
CONTROL 10
COMMUNICATION 10
DANGEROUS PLAY 10
FITNESS 10
ATTITUDE 10
OVERALL 9
OTHER COMMENTS Never saw any decision, PK or FK that left me wondering what it was for. Great dynamic communication helped the game to flow. Top performance

 

[Robert Burns]

Re: Referee Rating by Ian_Cook - Craig Joubert - England v Scotland (RWC 2011)

I can't disagree with that, I was at the game with reflink on and everything he did was spot on (apart from the touch judge telling him Knock on by England and him giving England the feed).

Once again he proved why he is rated so highly, and was the best man for the job!

Excellent Comms telling both Eng & Sco that he didn't want a conference at every line out.

Well done Craig!

 

[Robert Burns]

Referee Rating by Robert Burns - Craig Joubert - England v Scotland (RWC 2011)

BIASED REPORT Yes
OFFSIDES 10
ADVANTAGE 10
SCRUMS 10
RUCKS & MAULS 10
TACKLE 10
CONTROL 10
COMMUNICATION 10
DANGEROUS PLAY 10
FITNESS 10
ATTITUDE 10
OVERALL 10
OTHER COMMENTS I could find no fault with Craig's performance, surely top contender for the Final.