Cut referees slack - Justin Marshall

Drift


Referees in Australia
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
1,846
Post Likes
114
Current Referee grade:
Level 2
http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/opinion/8719136/Marshall-Cut-the-Super-Rugby-refs-some

It's time for a little perspective, and a little empathy. It's time, I reckon, that we ease off this assault on rugby's referees.

No, you are not imagining this. I am going to bat for referees everywhere for the job they do under the most trying of circumstances. And, yes, I hang my head in shame for all the verbals I've given them in my time.

Why now, you might ask? Well, you could say I saw the light in my second game of club rugby on Saturday, and it's given me a much better appreciation for the thankless job the man with the whistle does.

It's appropriate, too, to think about this because officials have come under some real heat in Super Rugby recently from coaches not happy with their lot in life.

Let me paint you the picture from our game on Saturday in Clyde. The referee turned up in his uniform and with his bag containing the two touch-judge flags, because at this level he would have to make do with a couple of reserves to be his "assistants".

It takes a special type of person to turn up on his own and referee, because he copped a constant battery of feedback throughout the game. There was no help from the touch-judges, and of course he missed a few things. But the thing that struck me, he was such a lonely figure. When I went to find him after the game to shake his hand he was already making his way out of the ground.

There he was, bag in hand, uniform still on, hopping in the car to head home. The players all go to the clubrooms to digest the match, but it's not so easy for the referee to relax and have a beer afterwards.

Too often when things don't go our way we want to point the finger at the referee. But it's not an easy job.

In the NRL they have much less complicated rules, and it's a much easier game to officiate. Yet they have two refs out there.

Rugby has more rules and less officials and we expect our refs to get every single decision right. I know as a player I did my fair share of moaning, but I can't help thinking that our expectations are unrealistic.

Of course at the top levels the ramifications of bad decisions can be catastrophic and big calls can change the balance of a game, or even a season.

But it's not an easy task picking everything up out there. I challenge any players griping at refs - Ali Williams springs to mind - whether they could do a better job.

Sure, they're paid to get it right, but nowhere near as much as players are paid. And, they're actually there for the betterment of the game; not to ruin it as a spectacle.

As a player sometimes I'd come off the field thinking I had a bad game, but thankfully my team-mates played well and we got away with a win.

But the ref can't do that. They're accountable, they're on their own and there's nowhere to hide. Sometimes they have an off day.

It hit me on Saturday what a hard and thankless job it is. This guy turns up, he's got no support, but he gives up his Saturday to referee a club game and puts up with what he had to.

Something had changed in me. In my first game back this season I was terrible. I swore, I backchatted. But I realised my expectations coming from professional to club level had been unrealistic.

So this time I grew up, shut up, pulled my head in and got on with it.

Then it struck home how vocal everyone was. He got his one cheer afterwards but by that time he was heading to his car.

Refs are there because they love the game, but it's just not easy. What sport has as many rules as rugby? I can't think of one that's close. The breakdown alone can have up to a dozen infringements.

They have the hardest job in all of sport.

I remember having a dig at Jonathon White for a last-minute penalty that cost the Bulls a win against the Brumbies. I thought it was an impulse decision that affected the outcome.

Somebody told me he's a heart surgeon in Auckland. That's his job. He doesn't need to be out there, but it's something he's passionate about. I thought 'good on you Jonathon White', you've reached the top in your field, and in your sport.

These guys are doing a thankless job in the most difficult sport to referee and maybe it's time we cut them some slack.

MARSHALL LORE: Silly me, picking against the Chiefs. They were defensively outstanding, and had an intelligent game plan that was implemented with ruthless precision. They deservedly top the NZ conference and I can't see them being knocked off the summit.

A week ago I said the Blues needed to start learning from their mistakes, stop making excuses and get on with it. They were good enough but needed to grow up. Instead they did the opposite, making the same mistakes against the Brumbies they had a week earlier in Christchurch. With a trip to South Africa in front of them, I fear their finals chances are fading.

Andrew Hore was benched by the Highlanders. But what a response from the veteran. His performance against the Force when injected was outstanding. He was everywhere and showed why he is an All Black - and will continue to be as long as he wants.

So who is the form team of Super Rugby? I reckon it's a tie. The Chiefs look the most likely title winners, but equally as impressive are the Bulls. They are demolishing all comers and beating the Sharks away was a big result. If they finish high enough, it's hard to see anyone beating them at home.


Decent article from Marshall here, sure he gets stuck into referees when they make a shocking call but lately I have noticed he has been a lot fairer on the refs.
 

Ian_Cook


Referees in New Zealand
Staff member
Joined
Jul 12, 2005
Messages
13,682
Post Likes
1,768
Current Referee grade:
Level 2
He would be even better if he learned some of the Laws of the game. Honestly, he has come out with some absolute howlers this year!

Also, he appears to have recently picked up a bad case "Stuart Barnes' Disease", which, as most of you know, has two obvious symptoms;

1. He wont shut the fvck up when the referee is explaining to a player what the penalty was for, and

2. He then asks his "colour" commentator if he knows what the penalty was for.

Fail!
 

The Fat


Referees in Australia
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
4,204
Post Likes
496
He would be even better if he learned some of the Laws of the game. Honestly, he has come out with some absolute howlers this year!

Also, he appears to have recently picked up a bad case "Stuart Barnes' Disease", which, as most of you know, has two obvious symptoms;

1. He wont shut the fvck up when the referee is explaining to a player what the penalty was for, and

2. He then asks his "colour" commentator if he knows what the penalty was for.

Fail!

But on the upside, Phil Kearns makes Justin look like an elite ref.
 

winchesterref


Referees in England
Joined
Dec 14, 2009
Messages
2,014
Post Likes
197
Current Referee grade:
Select Grade
JM called Nonu's red card fairly accurately at the weekend, which I was quite surprised with. I've heard him come out with some crap this year as well though!
 

Davet

Referee Advisor / Assessor
Joined
Jan 27, 2004
Messages
12,731
Post Likes
4
The bit I don't recognise in the article is the description of the ref turning up and then leaving - still in his uniform - without any interaction with the players or going to the clubhouse.

I would expect the ref to shower and change after the game, and to go for a beer (maybe only a soft drink if he's driving) and a chat with the players.

The other bit that struck me was
In my first game back this season I was terrible. I swore, I backchatted.
- so how did he not get pinged off the park and carded?
 

damo


Referees in New Zealand
Joined
May 5, 2011
Messages
1,692
Post Likes
276
It's an old article, but for some reason it has reappeared in a few places around the net today.

The bit I don't recognise in the article is the description of the ref turning up and then leaving - still in his uniform - without any interaction with the players or going to the clubhouse.

I would expect the ref to shower and change after the game, and to go for a beer (maybe only a soft drink if he's driving) and a chat with the players.
Normally refs socialise after the game, though I reckon down south the distances would be pretty big and maybe he just wanted to get home. Just browsing on here I get the impression that the culture is more ref friendly up north than it is down under. I could be wrong about that, just an impression.

The other bit that struck me was - so how did he not get pinged off the park and carded?
Probably because it probably wasn't as bad as he makes it out (I'll bet it was fairly good natured), and the poor ref was a bit star-struck coming up against 2 All Blacks.
 

Ian_Cook


Referees in New Zealand
Staff member
Joined
Jul 12, 2005
Messages
13,682
Post Likes
1,768
Current Referee grade:
Level 2
But on the upside, Phil Kearns makes Justin look like an elite ref.

True, but great at the after match barbecue...


"I'll have TWO sausages!!"
 

itin

New member
Joined
Mar 3, 2013
Messages
45
Post Likes
0
Current Referee grade:
Level 1
The bit I don't recognise in the article is the description of the ref turning up and then leaving - still in his uniform - without any interaction with the players or going to the clubhouse.

I would expect the ref to shower and change after the game, and to go for a beer (maybe only a soft drink if he's driving) and a chat with the players.

In this area it is very rare for the ref to come to the post match drink up.
 

Lee Lifeson-Peart


Referees in England
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
7,815
Post Likes
1,008
Current Referee grade:
Level 6
If I couldn't have a drink and a chat post match I don't think I'd bother doing it! hic!
 

Rushforth


Referees in Holland
Joined
Jan 19, 2011
Messages
1,300
Post Likes
92
It's a good question that I haven't given much thought. Just seems to be the way things are.

I don't know very much about USA rugby, but distances are bigger than Australia and South Africa; only Canada has bigger distances and I am fully aware that some teams will travel for a whole weekend for a match. Not that I had thought about the referee in that scenario.

I'm also "aware" (more film experience than matches watched, wink wink) that in American Football coaches will not let their players argue with the arbitrator. They'd rather do that themselves! (Again, pure speculation on my part).

One of the things which keeps me going is that even when players have disagreed with individual decisions (or lack thereof!) on the field of play, I cannot recall a single occasion when they did not accept, or better: tell me -after the match - that I was in any way biased. What they accept is that referees make mistakes, that those mistakes do go both ways, and so - after the match - they cut referees (me at least) some slack.

I can't communicate fast enough on the field to explain every decision. There is another team wanting to play the ball when there is a penalty, and although I regularly (at youth levels) don't allow the quick one, I would rather explain (decisions) over a friendly beer later for adults.

Blahblah :)
 

OB..


Referees in England
Staff member
Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Messages
22,981
Post Likes
1,838
It's a good question that I haven't given much thought. Just seems to be the way things are.
They don't seem to have trouble joining in when they come over here on exchange.
 

Browner

Banned
Joined
Jan 20, 2012
Messages
6,000
Post Likes
270
In this area it is very rare for the ref to come to the post match drink up.

Then IMHO everyone, Referees, Administrators, Coaches & supporters should encourage it ....... Warm & welcoming post match hospitality is the foundations upon which this great sport were built. It provides opportunities to build relationships, break down barriers & share knowledge etc My advise would be to find a way to foster it, it could be a Unique Selling Point that helps recruitment into the sport.
 

KieranW


Referees in England
Joined
Sep 17, 2012
Messages
209
Post Likes
0
Current Referee grade:
Level 8
If I were a football ref, I'd get paid something in the region of £20 a match, which for me is a decent night out. But the reception I get from the majority of the players and coaches makes it worthwhile (there are of course exceptions). I was invited out to an U17 teams end of season party after I refereed a couple of their matches and got on with the coach and the players after the match in the bar - the coach paid for my drinks and a 3 course meal! I got on with all the players too, turned out to be a really good day out. That's why I do this, without that interaction I don't think I'd find it worthwhile.
 

Phil E


Referees in England
Staff member
Joined
Jan 22, 2008
Messages
16,111
Post Likes
2,372
Current Referee grade:
Level 8
Kieran, I agree.
I was in the Navy for 24 years and I never thought, when I left, that I would replicate the camaraderie that I found in the Navy. But I did in Rugby, even as a referee. I wouldn't swap the football refs £20 a match (I think it might be more), for what I get from Rugby.
 

Browner

Banned
Joined
Jan 20, 2012
Messages
6,000
Post Likes
270
Browner

We agree entirely .

Eh, what, are you serious ...... i'm sure that's twice this year ! ............. That's it everyone I'm off to join Womblebollocks - and I'm gonna buy a Eurolottery ticket , cos I'm feeling blessed ...so I am, so I am :wink:
 

DrSTU


Referees in England
Joined
Dec 24, 2008
Messages
2,782
Post Likes
45
Two main reasons why refs tend not to go to the after-match function:

1: Distances, I may have driven 3 hours to get to the game and would like to get home on the same day!

2: There's a very dispersive nature after most games. Without the focal point of the clubhouse there is a tendency for players, coaches and fans to disperse and then reconvene a couple of hours later at an agreed place. This obviously means that the ref is "alone" for a long period of times and it doesn't seem worth hanging around a lot of the time.

For example, this weekend I left the house at 6 a.m. to drive up to Santa Monica for an 8 a.m. start (7s qualifier). The final was at 17:40 so we left the pitches at 18:20 and drove the 20 mins to the "local" bar (group of refs). By the time we left at 20:00 only 3 players had arrived from the home team. Then drove back to San Diego. Arriving home at 22:30. It's a long day and a lot of driving.
 
Last edited:
Top