CrouchTPEngage
Referees in England
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2009
- Messages
- 498
- Post Likes
- 58
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 8
I gotta say that I though Leicester and Newcastle, last night was superbly reffed by one of the best. Step forward Mr Luke Pearce and take a bow !
There was a lot of controversy over the last-minute ( and unfortunately highly-significant) try.
Mr Pearce says "I cannot see a grounding so I have to ask "Try Yes or No"".
There is then some good dialogue between TM and Mr Pearce which appears to centre around if the whistle was blown or not before the 2nd grounding of the ball.
Then Mr Pearce changes to "There is no evidence as to why I cannot award the try". This is now a different question to the "Try : Yes or No" question which was originally asked.
A brave call. And one I felt could have gone either way. I dont get TMOs at my level and, to be honest, its difficult for me to know if I would have awarded a try there or not.
Question is - can a ref change his question to the TMO from "Try Yes or No" to "Is there a reason why I cannot award a try" ? Especially given the context of "I could not see any clear grounding of the ball"?
There was a lot of controversy over the last-minute ( and unfortunately highly-significant) try.
Mr Pearce says "I cannot see a grounding so I have to ask "Try Yes or No"".
There is then some good dialogue between TM and Mr Pearce which appears to centre around if the whistle was blown or not before the 2nd grounding of the ball.
Then Mr Pearce changes to "There is no evidence as to why I cannot award the try". This is now a different question to the "Try : Yes or No" question which was originally asked.
A brave call. And one I felt could have gone either way. I dont get TMOs at my level and, to be honest, its difficult for me to know if I would have awarded a try there or not.
Question is - can a ref change his question to the TMO from "Try Yes or No" to "Is there a reason why I cannot award a try" ? Especially given the context of "I could not see any clear grounding of the ball"?