didds
Resident Club Coach
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2004
- Messages
- 12,069
- Post Likes
- 1,798
Well the way the Law is actually worded, yes, but I think its just poorly worded (nothing new there then)
totally agree.
How about a player cleaning out at a tackle, and a ruck forms behind him. Would you pull the trigger immediately for offside before he had a chance to retire? No? Then why would you if he drives through a ruck, or a maul for that matter?
you wouldn't necessarily ping him for offside because the laws make tio clear being offside in itself is not a PK offense.
However, the OP's description is not this case, but of a material act when in such an offside position. So its PK (advantage if possible but in this scenario unlikely probably).
didds