spikeno10
Player or Coach
- Joined
- Sep 20, 2010
- Messages
- 147
- Post Likes
- 0
Sunday morning refereeing a Colts game. Muddy conditions and raining hard throughout.
About 20 mins in a hard tackle on red 8 from Blue 13, man and ball and driven into the ground.
Initial contact was the ball but arm moved upwards from there, nothing much in it from my point of view.
Red 8 offloaded ball but then reacted to the tackler, not a punch but shoves and the like.
Results in mass run in, handbags and lots of whistle blowing from me.
Players separate themselves and I call captains to me. Red 8 is the captain.
Explained that it would be a penalty against Red for the reaction. Dismissed both coaches from the pitch who had come on with water "to calm the boys down".
Two phases of play later at a scrum I notice two of the centres throwing remarks at each other, "I'm going to smash you", etc. Both had been involved in the flash point early.
I broke the scrum up asked the captains to join me and gave both centres a YC for "unsportsmanlike play" - no other issues in the game after that.
Both coaches seemed happy enough.
Question is was that two harsh or should someone have gone at the flash point?
Appreciate any feedback.
I'm just a coach at a club who referees when asked, mainly youth games.
About 20 mins in a hard tackle on red 8 from Blue 13, man and ball and driven into the ground.
Initial contact was the ball but arm moved upwards from there, nothing much in it from my point of view.
Red 8 offloaded ball but then reacted to the tackler, not a punch but shoves and the like.
Results in mass run in, handbags and lots of whistle blowing from me.
Players separate themselves and I call captains to me. Red 8 is the captain.
Explained that it would be a penalty against Red for the reaction. Dismissed both coaches from the pitch who had come on with water "to calm the boys down".
Two phases of play later at a scrum I notice two of the centres throwing remarks at each other, "I'm going to smash you", etc. Both had been involved in the flash point early.
I broke the scrum up asked the captains to join me and gave both centres a YC for "unsportsmanlike play" - no other issues in the game after that.
Both coaches seemed happy enough.
Question is was that two harsh or should someone have gone at the flash point?
Appreciate any feedback.
I'm just a coach at a club who referees when asked, mainly youth games.