pombok
Referees in England
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2016
- Messages
- 22
- Post Likes
- 0
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 7
I had a game a couple of weeks ago that had me scratching my head.
Womens NC2 game so England Rugby Regulation 16 and 16 Amendment 1 come into play.
As it is NC2 we play under 19 law variations. Both teams have 15 players to start with but no replacements, so far so good.
Midway through the second half Team A's prop feels unwell and leaves the field. There is no front row replacement so we go to uncontested scrums.
Normal uncontested scrum law would mean that Team A drop a player (or cannot replace the injured player) and play with 14. 8 required in the scrum for uncontested so we have Team A with 14 players and Team B with 15.
Team A then loses their other prop to injury. Regulation 16 (app 1) 16.2.b says:
So I said that Team A now goes to 13 and Team B goes to 14. Team B still has the advantage of an extra player as Team A caused uncontested scrums. If not for the first injury causing uncontested (i.e. if it was a backline player that got injured) we would play 14 a side.
OR
After the second player got injured should we have played 13 on both sides so that there are the same number of players on the pitch?
Thoughts?
Womens NC2 game so England Rugby Regulation 16 and 16 Amendment 1 come into play.
As it is NC2 we play under 19 law variations. Both teams have 15 players to start with but no replacements, so far so good.
Midway through the second half Team A's prop feels unwell and leaves the field. There is no front row replacement so we go to uncontested scrums.
Normal uncontested scrum law would mean that Team A drop a player (or cannot replace the injured player) and play with 14. 8 required in the scrum for uncontested so we have Team A with 14 players and Team B with 15.
Team A then loses their other prop to injury. Regulation 16 (app 1) 16.2.b says:
National Challenge 2 and below(b) Matches can be played with reduced numbers to a minimum of 10 players a side. In allmatches, there must be the same number of players from each team on the field of play,subject to the laws of the game.
So I said that Team A now goes to 13 and Team B goes to 14. Team B still has the advantage of an extra player as Team A caused uncontested scrums. If not for the first injury causing uncontested (i.e. if it was a backline player that got injured) we would play 14 a side.
OR
After the second player got injured should we have played 13 on both sides so that there are the same number of players on the pitch?
Thoughts?