L'irlandais
, Promises to Referee in France
- Joined
- May 11, 2010
- Messages
- 4,724
- Post Likes
- 325
Game on.
Yer man from Gloucestershire in the middle.
Yer man from Gloucestershire in the middle.
12 and a half minutes gone. Ireland penalised at least 4 times for their players on the Welsh side of the breakdown not getting back on side quickly enough.
POC unhappy with that observation from Mr Barnes, as the Welsh players, off their feet on the Irish side of the ruck aren't all that swift either at getting out of the way. - Finally pinged them too.
Disagree. Thought he set a precedent in the first 25 which then allowed the game to flow - led to a brilliant last 35 minutes of rugby. Not sure how you can be unhappy as an Irish fan. 2 Yellows (both correct) and a pen try (also correct) in your favour! He didn't tolerate players slowing the ball down - at this level they are good enough to either move, or not be there in the first place, and that led to some good rugby. The Irish squandered chances (just as England did later against Scotland).
The FK he gave was clear - defintely was a cocked arm as i remember.
You can hardly blame him for his ARs call (if thats what you thought it was - couldn't hear what he actualy gave it for). Overall i thought he had a pretty good game. Certainly one of the better games of rugby I've watched for some time, and I think he had a hand in that.
Wales had a lot of the possession in the first 15 and he blew Ireland off the park. He was quick to penalise and gave the player little time to move away if they fell the wrong side. Correct calls in law and no issue with the decisions themselves. Wales kicked the 4 PKs and were 12-0 up. The issue however was that he did not apply a consistent rule and so when Wales infringed similarly later on in the game he did not penalise it and chose to manage it with preventative refereeing...a fair way to do it if you do it for 80 mins but not if you did not start that way. On the balance of the last 65mins he gave Wales 4 VERY soft PKs and 12 points in the first 15.
He did tolerate Welsh players slowing the ball in the 30 phase attack Ireland had and he allowed it to an extent he did not allow with Ireland at any time in the game. 2 deserved YCs and a PT but he missed the YC for Lydiate killing the quick ball Ireland had to exploit a 4 on 2. It was the first visit after the Warburton YC and was as nailed on as you need.
The scrum PK at the end was for whip wheeling but he PKed the wrong team totally. Wales were under pressure and looked to wheel Ireland blind when the ball came back Ireland's side. It was Wales who whip wheeled and that was clear. Ireland dominated the scrum and were punished with 3 totally incorrect calls.
Wales had a lot of the possession in the first 15 and he blew Ireland off the park. He was quick to penalise and gave the player little time to move away if they fell the wrong side. Correct calls in law and no issue with the decisions themselves. Wales kicked the 4 PKs and were 12-0 up. The issue however was that he did not apply a consistent rule and so when Wales infringed similarly later on in the game he did not penalise it and chose to manage it with preventative refereeing...a fair way to do it if you do it for 80 mins but not if you did not start that way. On the balance of the last 65mins he gave Wales 4 VERY soft PKs and 12 points in the first 15.
He did tolerate Welsh players slowing the ball in the 30 phase attack Ireland had and he allowed it to an extent he did not allow with Ireland at any time in the game. 2 deserved YCs and a PT but he missed the YC for Lydiate killing the quick ball Ireland had to exploit a 4 on 2. It was the first visit after the Warburton YC and was as nailed on as you need.
The scrum PK at the end was for whip wheeling but he PKed the wrong team totally. Wales were under pressure and looked to wheel Ireland blind when the ball came back Ireland's side. It was Wales who whip wheeled and that was clear. Ireland dominated the scrum and were punished with 3 totally incorrect calls.