FIXED:Question Reference Number: 294

[Ovey]

Blue #12 is just outside of their 22 and passes across the 22-metre line to Blue #14. Blue #14 kicks directly into touch at Gold's 10-metre line. What do you do?
Incorrect - You answered A.
The correct answer is: B.
19.1b : When a defending player plays the ball from outside the 22 and it goes into that player’s 22 or in-goal area without touching an opposition player and then that player or another player from that team kicks the ball directly into touch before it touches an opposition player, or a tackle takes place or a ruck or maul is formed, there is no gain in ground. This applies when a defending player moves back behind the 22 metre line to take a quick throw-in and then the ball is kicked directly into touch.

A. Award a line-out to Gold opposite the place where Blue kicked the ball.
B. Award a line-out to Gold where the ball went into touch.
C. Award a line-out to Blue opposite the place where Blue #14 kicked the ball.
D. Award a line-out to Blue where the ball went into touch.

I thought that if a ball was carried or passed back in to the 22 and kicked out on the full, that it resulted in a line-out level with where the kicker last played the ball? I'm confused now!!

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

For B to be the ' correct' answer the ball would have to be out of play and passed back over the 22 for his team mate to take a free kick from the indicated mark.:hap:

 

[OB..]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

I agree the correct answer is A. I don't think the quiz has been fully updated.

For B to be the ' correct' answer the ball would have to be out of play and passed back over the 22 for his team mate to take a free kick from the indicated mark.:hap:

What free kick? What indicated mark? Blue 12 is outside the 22, passing the ball back into it.

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

I agree the correct answer is A. I don't think the quiz has been fully updated.
What free kick? What indicated mark? Blue 12 is outside the 22, passing the ball back into it.

Why the , OB. If the answer to the scenario described is B, then my answer is correct. You're assuming this happened during play so as to make your answer correct.

 

[Phil E]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Why the , OB. If the answer to the scenario described is B, then my answer is correct. You're assuming this happened during play so as to make your answer correct.

But B isn't the right answer.
A is the right answer. The quiz hasn't been fully updated.

I thought that had been explained.
I can explain again in words of one syllable if it will help?

 

[The umpire]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

For B to be the ' correct' answer the ball would have to be out of play and passed back over the 22 for his team mate to take a free kick from the indicated mark.:hap:

Then blue#12 wouldn't be described as "just outside of their 22" he'd be "off the playing area" which would be completely different question.

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

But B isn't the right answer.
A is the right answer. The quiz hasn't been fully updated.

I thought that had been explained.
I can explain again in words of one syllable if it will help?[/


Phil, my scenario justified B as being correct. Why belittle my answer?:sad:

 

[Phil E]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

But B isn't the right answer.
A is the right answer. The quiz hasn't been fully updated.

I thought that had been explained.
I can explain again in words of one syllable if it will help?

Phil, my scenario justified B as being correct. Why belittle my answer?:sad:

A is right.
B is not.
Quiz is bust.

I can say it slower as well if that helps?

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Then blue#12 wouldn't be described as "just outside of their 22" he'd be "off the playing area" which would be completely different question.

Free kick awarded just inside 22. Ball loose just outside still in FoP. :hap:

. . . . why the attitude? I'm only offering an alternative viewpoint?:sad:

 

[Phil E]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Free kick awarded just inside 22. Ball loose just outside still in FoP. :hap:

Have you been drinking?

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

A is right.
B is not.
Quiz is bust.

I can say it slower as well if that helps?

What on earth's with you Phil? I recognise and accept what you're saying.

Not knowing the quiz was incorrect, I was only justifying why B could be a correct answer.:sad:

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Have you been drinking?

Can B be the answer to the scenario I proposed and was also described in Ovey's thread, Phil . . . please?

 

[Phil E]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Can B be the answer to the scenario I proposed and was also described in Ovey's thread, Phil . . . please?

Here's an idea. Pick any answer from the quiz, then make up your own fantasy question to make the answer fit (in your world).

Do this a few times then open your own website with "Choppers Fantasy Rugby Quiz (no law knowledge required)".

That's what the ref rote.

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

You just don't get it do you, Phil? But then it really doesn't matter.:hap:

 

[Phil E]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

You just don't get it do you, Phil? But then it really doesn't matter.:hap:

......and there was me thinking you were the one who just didn't get it?

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Very true.:hap:

 

[dave_clark]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

Free kick awarded just inside 22. Ball loose just outside still in FoP. :hap:

. . . . why the attitude? I'm only offering an alternative viewpoint?:sad:

free kick taken from the wrong place. scrum down, opposition ball.

i don't understand your alternative viewpoint. have you made up a scenario and then answered it? well done.

 

[chopper15]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

free kick taken from the wrong place. scrum down, opposition ball.

i don't understand your alternative viewpoint. have you made up a scenario and then answered it? well done.

My comment was to clarify thread #6 to justify the incorrect answer, dave.:hap:

By the way what exactly was the corrected question?

 

[OB..]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

My comment was to clarify thread #6 to justify the incorrect answer, dave.:hap:

You came up with a scenario in your own mind in order to make B the correct answer. Unfortunately you did not bother to state it, merely bringing in a couple of points not raised in the original question. When I asked about them you did not explain.

Eventually you got round to it.

Free kick awarded just inside 22. Ball loose just outside still in FoP. :hap:

Yes, that would work, but why not say so to start with?

I still regard it as unhelpful, since there is no hint at all in the question of the scenario you have devised.

 

[Drift]

Re: Question Reference Number: 294

What on earth's with you Phil? I recognise and accept what you're saying.

Not knowing the quiz was incorrect, I was only justifying why B could be a correct answer.:sad:

Chopper if the situation you described was happening it would've been described in the question.
You are wrong, A is the correct answer