Crucial
Rugby Expert
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2014
- Messages
- 278
- Post Likes
- 79
- Current Referee grade:
- Select Grade
I'm interested in views regarding this incident.
https://assets.stuff...8-neck grab.mp4
Personally I think this was an incredibly dangerous act that could have ended up in serious injury. Others have downplayed it somewhat.
I won't discuss too much at this point to not colour views but the facts are as follows
- blue 7 legally joins a driving maul with white already in possession and white 8 exposed .
- initially blue 7 binds with his left arm and has his right arm free
- white get bodies low and start to get drive going again
- blue 7 grasps white 8 around the neck
- the grasp is strong enough for white 8 to attempt to 'tap out' and alert blue 7 that he was in distress
- blue 7 continues with the hold and doesn't relax it even when the maul twists and collapses.
- white 8 remains on the ground indicating to his neck
- referee doesn't ask TMO for assistance but mentions that he is watching the screen replay as a player appears to have been held around the neck.
- the replay being shown doesn't actually show the player in question and ref says 'nothing for us' and asks the white captain what he is doing with the penalty.
Blue 7 has been cited after the game with.. 10.4 (e): Playing a player without the ball is dangerous play; and 10.4 (m): Acts contrary to good sportsmanship.
https://assets.stuff...8-neck grab.mp4
Personally I think this was an incredibly dangerous act that could have ended up in serious injury. Others have downplayed it somewhat.
I won't discuss too much at this point to not colour views but the facts are as follows
- blue 7 legally joins a driving maul with white already in possession and white 8 exposed .
- initially blue 7 binds with his left arm and has his right arm free
- white get bodies low and start to get drive going again
- blue 7 grasps white 8 around the neck
- the grasp is strong enough for white 8 to attempt to 'tap out' and alert blue 7 that he was in distress
- blue 7 continues with the hold and doesn't relax it even when the maul twists and collapses.
- white 8 remains on the ground indicating to his neck
- referee doesn't ask TMO for assistance but mentions that he is watching the screen replay as a player appears to have been held around the neck.
- the replay being shown doesn't actually show the player in question and ref says 'nothing for us' and asks the white captain what he is doing with the penalty.
Blue 7 has been cited after the game with.. 10.4 (e): Playing a player without the ball is dangerous play; and 10.4 (m): Acts contrary to good sportsmanship.