Mouth Guard

[thepercy]

https://i.stuff.co.nz/sport/rugby/a...with-ardie-savea-still-not-wearing-mouthguard

Is there any good reason why mouth guards are not required equipment in the laws of the game?

If WR were serious about concussion then it would be.

 

[buff]

Maybe because there is no real evidence that they have any impact on concussions.
From the British Journal of Sports Medicine
The ability of mouthguards to protect against head and spinal injuries in sport falls into the realm of “neuromythology” rather than hard science.32 Reading the original studies cited as evidence for this effect reveals anecdotal claims that can best be described as bizarre rather than reflecting established medical principles. It is unlikely that a mouthguard would offer effective protection against brain or spinal cord injury, and the limited published data are not compelling in this regard nor does it accord with the known pathophysiology of such injuries.

Now if we were talking about injuries to the teeth and gums, then there is a valid point to be made.

 

[crossref]

Now if we were talking about injuries to the teeth and gums, then there is a valid point to be made.[/FONT][/COLOR]

also - vitally - protecting other people -- i heard of a ref who pulled a player's tooth out of another player's scalp

 

[buff]

also - vitally - protecting other people -- i heard of a ref who pulled a player's tooth out of another player's scalp

Agreed.

 

[Jz558]

I have a friend who still has a large scar below his bottom lip where his top set of teeth went through the skin and met his bottom set of teeth the otherside as his herculean efforts to tackle a flying wedge on his own proved an unwise decision. The injury happend in an under 15 game in the early 1980s. The school made gumshields mandatory after that.

 

[damo]

They are mandatory in NZ at every level below Super Rugby.

Realistically they are mandatory at all levels. Ardie Savea is an idiot for not wearing one.

I played in the late 90's and early 2000's. I would not have dreamed of playing without one.

 

[thepercy]

They are mandatory in NZ at every level below Super Rugby.

Realistically they are mandatory at all levels. Ardie Savea is an idiot for not wearing one.

I played in the late 90's and early 2000's. I would not have dreamed of playing without one.

What happens if you discover a player does not have a mouth guard during play? Is there a PK? Card? Stop the match or play down a man while getting it out of the kit bag? Mandatory substitution? Something else?

 

[buff]

For age grade rugby here we check before the game.

 

[damo]

What happens if you discover a player does not have a mouth guard during play? Is there a PK? Card? Stop the match or play down a man while getting it out of the kit bag? Mandatory substitution? Something else?

I am now an ex referee.

However my understanding is that the rule changed a season or two ago. Now it is a yellow card. I understand that there is an unwritten rule that if a player from the other team points it out, the player is not yellow carded but must leave the field to get the mouthguard.

Active referees might know more than me.