Crucial
Rugby Expert
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2014
- Messages
- 278
- Post Likes
- 79
- Current Referee grade:
- Select Grade
A few folk perplexed on Friday night regarding a TMO call on the Blues v Highlanders Super rugby game.
Now I may be unaware of some new direction or protocol given to the TMO to work with or maybe this was simply poor communication but it went something like this.
Yellow on attack with a tackle/ruck near the line. Yellow pick and go around the fringe. Blue hand dislodges ball forward into clear space. Yellow 7 scoops ball off ground stands and pops pass to yellow 9 who scores in the corner. Ref calls for TMO to see what happened with the ball spilling loose.
It was easily seen from the replay that the first 'wrong' was a KO by Blue but the TMO then carefully looks at the pickup by Yellow 7. When viewed frame by frame it appears that he bounces the ball forward from one hand into the other and that in the process it left his first touch for a brief moment.
Now if it was a KO then it was for a split second but still a KO.
The TMO comes back to the ref with a call of 'you can award a try. The KO was from Blue and advantage applies'. The ref asks him if he was happy with the pickup by Yellow 7 to which the reply was 'In real time it looked OK'.
Eh what? In real time the horse I bet on won but the bookies are paying on the photo!
To wind up the home crowd even more Blue were denied a try moments later for a forward pass that was judged in slo-mo but probably wasn't C&O in real time.
Here is the moment in question. so you get a better idea. Sadly I don't have a clip of the replays and TMO judgement.
https://youtu.be/KDsgDUmEXms?t=1m5s
Now I may be unaware of some new direction or protocol given to the TMO to work with or maybe this was simply poor communication but it went something like this.
Yellow on attack with a tackle/ruck near the line. Yellow pick and go around the fringe. Blue hand dislodges ball forward into clear space. Yellow 7 scoops ball off ground stands and pops pass to yellow 9 who scores in the corner. Ref calls for TMO to see what happened with the ball spilling loose.
It was easily seen from the replay that the first 'wrong' was a KO by Blue but the TMO then carefully looks at the pickup by Yellow 7. When viewed frame by frame it appears that he bounces the ball forward from one hand into the other and that in the process it left his first touch for a brief moment.
Now if it was a KO then it was for a split second but still a KO.
The TMO comes back to the ref with a call of 'you can award a try. The KO was from Blue and advantage applies'. The ref asks him if he was happy with the pickup by Yellow 7 to which the reply was 'In real time it looked OK'.
Eh what? In real time the horse I bet on won but the bookies are paying on the photo!
To wind up the home crowd even more Blue were denied a try moments later for a forward pass that was judged in slo-mo but probably wasn't C&O in real time.
Here is the moment in question. so you get a better idea. Sadly I don't have a clip of the replays and TMO judgement.
https://youtu.be/KDsgDUmEXms?t=1m5s