talbazar
Referees in Singapore
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2010
- Messages
- 702
- Post Likes
- 81
Let me try something....
The events as I see them (with replays and slow mo):
1. Kick (with 3 chasers offside by around 50cm which I'm happy to mark "not C&O")
2. White X jumps and touches the ball
3. The ball goes backwards
4. The ball hits the post and bounces back infield
5. White 4 (in an offside position from White X) grabs the ball and boots it away
6. Red 11 and red 22(with shiny boots) arrive
Analysis:
1. I chose to discard the chasers offside/onside because it's a 52m kick and these 50cm are not critical at landing. Furthermore I believe red 22 is onside which even in a "beam red 11 up Scotty" approach doesn't change the situation at landing.
2. White X intentionally plays the play the ball in what looks like "an attempt to prevent a penalty goal being scored" - PK offence
3. White 4 is offside and interfere with play - PK offence (unless you decide to be super emphatic and go for a scrum for unintentional but remember there is no knock on here)
Conclusion:
Good luck with your secondary signal :biggrin:, but no issue with PK against White, 5m in front of the posts.
My 2 cents,
Pierre.
The events as I see them (with replays and slow mo):
1. Kick (with 3 chasers offside by around 50cm which I'm happy to mark "not C&O")
2. White X jumps and touches the ball
3. The ball goes backwards
4. The ball hits the post and bounces back infield
5. White 4 (in an offside position from White X) grabs the ball and boots it away
6. Red 11 and red 22(with shiny boots) arrive
Analysis:
1. I chose to discard the chasers offside/onside because it's a 52m kick and these 50cm are not critical at landing. Furthermore I believe red 22 is onside which even in a "beam red 11 up Scotty" approach doesn't change the situation at landing.
2. White X intentionally plays the play the ball in what looks like "an attempt to prevent a penalty goal being scored" - PK offence
3. White 4 is offside and interfere with play - PK offence (unless you decide to be super emphatic and go for a scrum for unintentional but remember there is no knock on here)
Conclusion:
Good luck with your secondary signal :biggrin:, but no issue with PK against White, 5m in front of the posts.
My 2 cents,
Pierre.