Greg Collins
Referees in England
- Joined
- Feb 8, 2007
- Messages
- 2,856
- Post Likes
- 1
At our last Society training session I was introduced to the concept of the "credible put-in" at the scrum which is apparently now a part of the protocol in the Guinness Premiership. Seems a good idea and I've used that very phrase in my SH briefing and it seems to work
Elsewhere in this forum I've seen debate about line out throw in, on Saturday (Level 12 league game) I set myself the task of setting a reasonable, aka credible, standard for not straight at the line out and as a result was thanked by both teams for being a) consistent and b) allowing a little latitude unless "the throw was taking the piss" Not sure I got it right though so hear goes.....
a) Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is not dead straight but not by much, still more-or-less down the middle i.e. it was a credible throw, blue compete, yellow catch. I play on, correct or no?
b)Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is not straight but not by much, still more-or-less down the middle, i.e. it was a credible throw, blue compete, yellow compete, blue catch. I play on, correct or no?
c)Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is obviously not straight by a half a metre or more, i.e. an incredible throw in, in favour of yellow, blue compete yellow catch, I blow for "not straight" correct or no?
d)Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is obviously not straight by a half a metre or more, i.e. an incredible throw in, throw favours yellow, blue compete, yellow compete, blue catch I play advantage correct or no?
e) Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is obviously not straight by a half a metre or more, i.e. an incredible throw in, throw favours blue, blue compete, yellow compete, blue catch, I play advantage correct or no?
Elsewhere in this forum I've seen debate about line out throw in, on Saturday (Level 12 league game) I set myself the task of setting a reasonable, aka credible, standard for not straight at the line out and as a result was thanked by both teams for being a) consistent and b) allowing a little latitude unless "the throw was taking the piss" Not sure I got it right though so hear goes.....
a) Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is not dead straight but not by much, still more-or-less down the middle i.e. it was a credible throw, blue compete, yellow catch. I play on, correct or no?
b)Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is not straight but not by much, still more-or-less down the middle, i.e. it was a credible throw, blue compete, yellow compete, blue catch. I play on, correct or no?
c)Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is obviously not straight by a half a metre or more, i.e. an incredible throw in, in favour of yellow, blue compete yellow catch, I blow for "not straight" correct or no?
d)Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is obviously not straight by a half a metre or more, i.e. an incredible throw in, throw favours yellow, blue compete, yellow compete, blue catch I play advantage correct or no?
e) Yellow throw in a line out. Throw is obviously not straight by a half a metre or more, i.e. an incredible throw in, throw favours blue, blue compete, yellow compete, blue catch, I play advantage correct or no?