The difficulty with that is the player in question here (#8) may well not have been involved in the brief. At young age group level I have always allowed the retake for the first cock-up - and I see no issue allowing each team one error. But with teams that have been playing for several years, they should know better - and a harsh lesson will be the most effective tool in ensuring they learn the lesson.
if they are 12 yrs old, then it's different, yes.
but at older levels I always have the SH, captain present, and almost always the coach is there as well.
I tell the the SH and capt they must take quick taps properly (explain) and tell the capt/coacj that if anyone other than the SH is likely to take a tap, then relay to whole team.