talbazar
Referees in Singapore
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2010
- Messages
- 702
- Post Likes
- 81
Hi All,
I did have a look but didn't find this exact subject. So accept my apologies if it's already somewhere.
That could happen in open play, but most often than not in a line out, so that's the scenario I'll describe.
Blue vs. Red
Line out, Blue throw in.
Blue Second pod jumps and catches (no issue with the throw or the catch)
Blue jumper gets down, ball in hand and support players bind in a maul-like formation (binding is done behind the ball carrier, all legal there)
Red decide not to challenge the maul-like formation. They do not leave the line out (so no PK there)
Blue Jumper keeps the ball (all good there)
Red #2, alone, goes and tackle the ball carrier.
In your view, what just happened?
a) If the tackle is successful
1.a. Maul formed and collapsed in the same move?
or
2.a. Just a tackle, play on with that
b) If the tackle is not successful and only Red #2 goes to ground
1.b. Maul formed?
or
2.b Attempted tackle, no maul formed, we are still in this maul-like formation and admitting Blue haven't moved, the line out hasn't ended?
I do have my views on this, but I would love to have a broader "poll" on this...
Thanks a lot,
Pierre.
I did have a look but didn't find this exact subject. So accept my apologies if it's already somewhere.
That could happen in open play, but most often than not in a line out, so that's the scenario I'll describe.
Blue vs. Red
Line out, Blue throw in.
Blue Second pod jumps and catches (no issue with the throw or the catch)
Blue jumper gets down, ball in hand and support players bind in a maul-like formation (binding is done behind the ball carrier, all legal there)
Red decide not to challenge the maul-like formation. They do not leave the line out (so no PK there)
Blue Jumper keeps the ball (all good there)
Red #2, alone, goes and tackle the ball carrier.
In your view, what just happened?
a) If the tackle is successful
1.a. Maul formed and collapsed in the same move?
or
2.a. Just a tackle, play on with that
b) If the tackle is not successful and only Red #2 goes to ground
1.b. Maul formed?
or
2.b Attempted tackle, no maul formed, we are still in this maul-like formation and admitting Blue haven't moved, the line out hasn't ended?
I do have my views on this, but I would love to have a broader "poll" on this...
Thanks a lot,
Pierre.