...When you punt or drop kick the ball you release it forwards - again, technically illegal, but you certainly shoudl not set about penalising it.
Can we not (legaly) kick this spurios nonsense into touch?
Kicking the ball is part of the Laws. Both kicking from hand and drop kicking the ball are both 100% legal and in now way, technical or otherwise, illegal! In fact the laws of the game clearly states they are legall and can in no way be called "technically illegal"?
[LAWS]D
DEFINITIONS
D
Drop-kick: After being intentionally dropped to the ground from the hand or hands, the ball
is kicked as it rises from its first bounce.
K
Kick: An act made by intentionally hitting the ball with any part of the leg or foot, except the
heel, from the toe to the knee but not including the knee. A kick must move the ball a visible
distance out of the hand, or along the ground.
[/LAWS]
If those two definitions do not prove the absurd nature of such a claim what will? To add "proof" why would you be given points for a "technically illegal" act? The laws even tells you how to do it.
YOu comparison with the hand off is valid. The law's only reference (pre chance) was that it was illegal. No form of exception was ever included in the Laws . But kicking? Come off it.