Baylion
Getting to know the game
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2014
- Messages
- 88
- Post Likes
- 17
- Current Referee grade:
- Select Grade
During the Super Rugby season we saw a number of knock on tries given by the TMOs because there wasn't "clear and obvious separation", often due to camera angles. The "worst" was Dillyn Leyds's try
https://youtu.be/fPgA9lmE8Dw
But there were others, which I cannot specifically remember.
From commentary during the SA vs Pumas test it seems the instruction went out that "If it looks like a knock on it is a knock on" resulting in Lionel Mapoe's "try" being denied by the TMO. I haven't been able to trace a specific Law Clarification or instruction or a video of Mapoe's "try" but he dived over losing control but the ball remained in contact with his body. A try would have been given during Super Rugby but not with the new instructions
"If it looks like a knock on it is a knock on" Good thing or bad thing?
https://youtu.be/fPgA9lmE8Dw
But there were others, which I cannot specifically remember.
From commentary during the SA vs Pumas test it seems the instruction went out that "If it looks like a knock on it is a knock on" resulting in Lionel Mapoe's "try" being denied by the TMO. I haven't been able to trace a specific Law Clarification or instruction or a video of Mapoe's "try" but he dived over losing control but the ball remained in contact with his body. A try would have been given during Super Rugby but not with the new instructions
"If it looks like a knock on it is a knock on" Good thing or bad thing?