menace
Referees in Australia
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2009
- Messages
- 3,657
- Post Likes
- 633
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 2
Watching the ire vs fra rwc2015 and early in NO PKs France for offside when in front of last person who played the ball. On first sighting I had no issue (and still don't really) so I don't have an issue with the decision NO made at what he saw but it did make me wonder at what point is the offside line created and maintained when a player touched the ball but does not hold it and the player that last touched it has moved. So is it where the ball is touched or the player (that does not have possession of the ball). Ie does the offside player need to behind the point of contact with the ball or behind the player (even though they don't have the ball) before they are put back onside and can play at the ball.
Law says
[LAWS](a) Action by the player. When the offside player runs behind the team-mate who last kicked, touched or carried the ball, the player is put onside.[/LAWS]
In this case
Picture 1 shows the point at where a fra player last touched the ball
View attachment 3319
Picture 2 shows the point where the offside player plays at the ball and the player that last touched it lying on his back (some metres further from where he last touched)
View attachment 3320
If you use the mown grass strip as the line of reference (hopefully you can see it) just behind where the offside player picks up the ball, it is pretty clear he picks up the ball some metres 'behind' where it was last touched (but still in front of the player that touched it).
I know the law says be behind player, but is that what is intended when they don't have possession and when both the ball and player have moved?
(God damn iPad always posts my photos upside down - frigged if I know why )
Law says
[LAWS](a) Action by the player. When the offside player runs behind the team-mate who last kicked, touched or carried the ball, the player is put onside.[/LAWS]
In this case
Picture 1 shows the point at where a fra player last touched the ball
View attachment 3319
Picture 2 shows the point where the offside player plays at the ball and the player that last touched it lying on his back (some metres further from where he last touched)
View attachment 3320
If you use the mown grass strip as the line of reference (hopefully you can see it) just behind where the offside player picks up the ball, it is pretty clear he picks up the ball some metres 'behind' where it was last touched (but still in front of the player that touched it).
I know the law says be behind player, but is that what is intended when they don't have possession and when both the ball and player have moved?
(God damn iPad always posts my photos upside down - frigged if I know why )
Last edited by a moderator: