- red knock on over blue's 22m line, into blue's 22
- blue gather the ball and kick for touch, do they get gain in ground?
before answering consider knock-on over other lines
1 red knock on into blue in-goal, blue do NOT get to touch it down for a 22m
2 red knock on over blue DBL, blue do NOT get a 22m
3 but red knock on into touch, blue DO get a lineout (if they want one, of course they can also choose a scrum)
the last one is relatively new - until last season a knock on over the touch line did not lead to a line out. Until that changed we had a consistent principle that knocking on over a line didn't really count as putting the ball over the line, but now it can.
So - gain in ground ?
- blue gather the ball and kick for touch, do they get gain in ground?
before answering consider knock-on over other lines
1 red knock on into blue in-goal, blue do NOT get to touch it down for a 22m
2 red knock on over blue DBL, blue do NOT get a 22m
3 but red knock on into touch, blue DO get a lineout (if they want one, of course they can also choose a scrum)
the last one is relatively new - until last season a knock on over the touch line did not lead to a line out. Until that changed we had a consistent principle that knocking on over a line didn't really count as putting the ball over the line, but now it can.
So - gain in ground ?