Ovey
Referees in England
Hi all, long time, no post for various reasons!
On saturday I had a L9 game, that was actually a good standard and could have been higher, however.....
Last minute (last kick of the game), score is 26-26, and red awarded a penalty half way inside the blue 22, about 6m in from the left touchline. Skipper chooses to kick at goal. Kicking tee brought on, blue all behind their own line, all going well.
A vocal Red 7 stands there saying to the kicker, "just dink it forward and I'll run on and pick it up, can we do that Sir?" I smile and his skipper tells him to shut up.
Kick is taken, but two inexperienced blue players attempt to charge the kick (which misses). I call for a re-take due to the charges and warn blue.
Vocal red 7 pipes up again, "can we change our mind and go for touch Sir?" Skipper pipes up and once again tells him to shut up and the kick is taken. Kick misses, final score 26-26.
My question is twofold:
1. Can the kicker "dink" the ball forwards and one of his (onside) players pick it up, despite the call of going for goal?
2. Could the retake have been changed to a different option, bearing in mind that the original decision was to kick at goal and it was an infringement during this choice that caused the kick to be retaken?
My take on 1 is that it's contrary to the spirit of the game but legal. As for 2, I don't know!
Cheers guys.
On saturday I had a L9 game, that was actually a good standard and could have been higher, however.....
Last minute (last kick of the game), score is 26-26, and red awarded a penalty half way inside the blue 22, about 6m in from the left touchline. Skipper chooses to kick at goal. Kicking tee brought on, blue all behind their own line, all going well.
A vocal Red 7 stands there saying to the kicker, "just dink it forward and I'll run on and pick it up, can we do that Sir?" I smile and his skipper tells him to shut up.
Kick is taken, but two inexperienced blue players attempt to charge the kick (which misses). I call for a re-take due to the charges and warn blue.
Vocal red 7 pipes up again, "can we change our mind and go for touch Sir?" Skipper pipes up and once again tells him to shut up and the kick is taken. Kick misses, final score 26-26.
My question is twofold:
1. Can the kicker "dink" the ball forwards and one of his (onside) players pick it up, despite the call of going for goal?
2. Could the retake have been changed to a different option, bearing in mind that the original decision was to kick at goal and it was an infringement during this choice that caused the kick to be retaken?
My take on 1 is that it's contrary to the spirit of the game but legal. As for 2, I don't know!
Cheers guys.