This is scenario 2 as mentioned in post 31 and replied to by DickieE. r.
No.. and its important difference.. was there actually a throw , or not
There are two key questions
1 does the thrower actually have to throw it, at the blocker, for the blocker to be penalised ? Or will you penalise the blocker when he is successful in preventing even the atrempt at a throw (tjr thrower gives up)
2 when yii do sanctiin, which is better a FK or a PK