A player ( Green ) outside the touch line propels the ball with his hand into play . The ball bounces between touch and the 5m line . The opposition ( red) collect the ball and run down to the goal line .
The referee consults the AR and asks whether there is any reason not to award a try . The reply was that the red player prevented the ball traveling 5 m and therefore a FK to Green .
This is a question as traveling 5 means that it must travel 5m before it touches the ground . 19.6 also says that it should go along the line of touch and therefore refers to a formed line out .
The decision if based on that this was a quick throw must be considered that a quick stands on its own and is not a part of the laws on Line out .
Then it should be under law 19.2 (e) which means reds has the option of a line out or scrum .
Would you play advantage to reds on the basis that green failed to throw 5 meters
The referee consults the AR and asks whether there is any reason not to award a try . The reply was that the red player prevented the ball traveling 5 m and therefore a FK to Green .
This is a question as traveling 5 means that it must travel 5m before it touches the ground . 19.6 also says that it should go along the line of touch and therefore refers to a formed line out .
The decision if based on that this was a quick throw must be considered that a quick stands on its own and is not a part of the laws on Line out .
Then it should be under law 19.2 (e) which means reds has the option of a line out or scrum .
Would you play advantage to reds on the basis that green failed to throw 5 meters