Arabcheif
Player or Coach
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2018
- Messages
- 680
- Post Likes
- 74
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 1
One of the other threads has got me wondering.
If I'm reffing a match and a player commits a YC offence AND denies a clear try scoring opportunity, I'm giving the PT. My question is as the protocol for a PT is to issue a YC automatically. Should you wait and issue the YC after the PT or issue it for the offence?
And if you YC the offence, then award the PT, technically this should be a YC too. So should you then issue a 2nd yellow? This seems overly harsh to me personally. I'd think it makes more sense to issue the YC after the PT.
Or is the timing of the YC irrelevant here. EG you can give the YC then the PT?
If I'm reffing a match and a player commits a YC offence AND denies a clear try scoring opportunity, I'm giving the PT. My question is as the protocol for a PT is to issue a YC automatically. Should you wait and issue the YC after the PT or issue it for the offence?
And if you YC the offence, then award the PT, technically this should be a YC too. So should you then issue a 2nd yellow? This seems overly harsh to me personally. I'd think it makes more sense to issue the YC after the PT.
Or is the timing of the YC irrelevant here. EG you can give the YC then the PT?
Last edited: