Ovey
Referees in England
Question Reference Number: 399
The Blue ball-carrier runs towards Gold's goal-line and is tackled there. The ball-carrier dives forward into in-goal, but the ball is dislodged from his grasp and falls straight down. The ball lands on the ground with the Blue player on top of it facing up. The ball is under his back. What do you do?
A. Award a try to Blue.
B. Award a scrum, with Blue throwing-in, five metres from the goal-line and in line with where the ball landed.
C. Award a scrum, with Gold throwing-in, five metres from the goal-line and in line with where the ball landed.
D. Award a drop-out to Gold; a drop-kick taken anywhere on or behind the 22-metre line.
Incorrect - You answered C.
The correct answer is: B.
22.1 : There are two ways a player can ground a ball in in-goal: by holding (holding in the hand or hands, or in the arm or arms) the ball and touching the ground with it (no downward pressure required) or when the ball is on the ground and a player presses down on it with a hand or hands, arm or arms, or the front of the player's body from waist to neck inclusive. The ball was not grounded, but held up, thus a 5-metre scrum is awarded to the attacking team.
I'm confused here - why isn't Gold given a scrum for a knock forward (dropped in the process of trying to ground)? I can't understand why the scrum is given as though the blue player was held up. Any ideas, or have I totally misunderstood the question and answer?
The Blue ball-carrier runs towards Gold's goal-line and is tackled there. The ball-carrier dives forward into in-goal, but the ball is dislodged from his grasp and falls straight down. The ball lands on the ground with the Blue player on top of it facing up. The ball is under his back. What do you do?
A. Award a try to Blue.
B. Award a scrum, with Blue throwing-in, five metres from the goal-line and in line with where the ball landed.
C. Award a scrum, with Gold throwing-in, five metres from the goal-line and in line with where the ball landed.
D. Award a drop-out to Gold; a drop-kick taken anywhere on or behind the 22-metre line.
Incorrect - You answered C.
The correct answer is: B.
22.1 : There are two ways a player can ground a ball in in-goal: by holding (holding in the hand or hands, or in the arm or arms) the ball and touching the ground with it (no downward pressure required) or when the ball is on the ground and a player presses down on it with a hand or hands, arm or arms, or the front of the player's body from waist to neck inclusive. The ball was not grounded, but held up, thus a 5-metre scrum is awarded to the attacking team.
I'm confused here - why isn't Gold given a scrum for a knock forward (dropped in the process of trying to ground)? I can't understand why the scrum is given as though the blue player was held up. Any ideas, or have I totally misunderstood the question and answer?