menace
Referees in Australia
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2009
- Messages
- 3,657
- Post Likes
- 633
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 2
We have reached the right final, but in totally the wrong way. As a result of France's capitulation, NZ has had only one real challenge - the Semi-Final against SA. Australia on the other hand has had to defeat England, Fiji, Wales and Argentina, and rely on the referee to overcome a huge Scottish challenge. That's 5 tough games against top-10 teams in five weeks, coupled with a day less to prepare for the final. World Rugby should hang its head in shame.
We have reached the right final, but in totally the wrong way. As a result of France's capitulation, NZ has had only one real challenge - the Semi-Final against SA. Australia on the other hand has had to defeat England, Fiji, Wales and Argentina, and rely on the referee to overcome a huge Scottish challenge. That's 5 tough games against top-10 teams in five weeks, coupled with a day less to prepare for the final. World Rugby should hang its head in shame.
We have reached the right final, but in totally the wrong way. As a result of France's capitulation, NZ has had only one real challenge - the Semi-Final against SA. Australia on the other hand has had to defeat England, Fiji, Wales and Argentina, and rely on the referee to overcome a huge Scottish challenge. That's 5 tough games against top-10 teams in five weeks, coupled with a day less to prepare for the final. World Rugby should hang its head in shame.
We have reached the right final, but in totally the wrong way. As a result of France's capitulation, NZ has had only one real challenge - the Semi-Final against SA. Australia on the other hand has had to defeat England, Fiji, Wales and Argentina, and rely on the referee to overcome a huge Scottish challenge. That's 5 tough games against top-10 teams in five weeks, coupled with a day less to prepare for the final. World Rugby should hang its head in shame.
Interesting that NZ are hot favourites... if you look at the teams they're almost the exact same teams that had Aus beat NZ by 8 points only a few months ago in the Tri (sorry Quad) Nations! Have the bookmakers got it wrong?
Interesting that NZ are hot favourites... if you look at the teams they're almost the exact same teams that had Aus beat NZ by 8 points only a few months ago in the Tri (sorry Quad) Nations! Have the bookmakers got it wrong?
Bookies are right though, NZ are clear favourites from a statistical point of view - which is all that bookies are interested in and thats why they make the money and not the punters.
Interesting that NZ are hot favourites... if you look at the teams they're almost the exact same teams that had Aus beat NZ by 8 points only a few months ago in the Tri (sorry Quad) Nations! Have the bookmakers got it wrong?
Possibly the other reason for the odds being strongly in the AB's favour is the rather odd decision to award the final to Owens, he has show an unconcious bias towards the AB's over many years, as most teams can attest to. Even the Kiwis openly acknowledge him as a 'friendly' referee.
These two teams are so close that it really is going to come down to 1-2% in performance and execution. The team that gets that 1-2% right will win.
I think you're flattering Australia....I think the divide is much bigger than that.
As others said - for any chance aust need to be 100% on their game and NZ need to drop off at least 10-20%. They won't. They're too clinical.
I think it is more that his 'style' suits NZ rather than any unconscious bias. His breakdown management is very different to WB (who allows a free for all) and he places value on the attacking team being able to recycle quickly. I don't think Moore would get away with the slow roll away that he did with WB and any defender that flops over the ball can expect a telling off.
He isn't trigger happy regarding breakdown steals and gives benefit of the doubt to the 'jackler' which plays as much into Australia's hands as NZs. Both McCaw and Pocock are expert of putting the ref in two minds as to whether they were legal. NO seems to try not to guess and assumes legality before illegality. He does appear to have a bee in his bonnet about hands on the deck/not supporting weight, which could go against Pocock who does this more than McCaw does.
It never seems that way when NZ is involved, and not just with Aus. France, England and Ireland have all been on the wrong end of it at different times!
.