Marc Wakeham
Referees in Wales
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2018
- Messages
- 2,779
- Post Likes
- 843
- Current Referee grade:
- Level 2
You brought him into the issue. The relevance is not there. The question is about the referee's actions.
2 - asking captains to 'go and have a word' - has that become over-used? is it useful, and if so for what? It's a good time to think about about *when* and *why* to do it. For me, I am going to use it less for a while, see what happens.
The problem was not the Time off and chat. The problem is with how PG managed it.
What, precisely, do we think PG should have done after Biggar asked him to let them know when it was going to be time on? I imagine there are a number of possibilities - what do we think he wishes he'd done?
What, precisely, do we think PG should have done after Biggar asked him to let them know when it was going to be time on? I imagine there are a number of possibilities - what do we think he wishes he'd done?
What, precisely, do we think PG should have done after Biggar asked him to let them know when it was going to be time on? I imagine there are a number of possibilities - what do we think he wishes he'd done?
Has anyone seen anything where PG says he doesn’t stand by what he did in this incident. Other than the misleading telegraph headline! I can’t find any actual quotes of him actually saying he believes he made a mistake in this incident.
Here's the quotejoel jutge did an interview in the french press, where reported the PG thought it was a mistake --- make of that what you will
https://www.midi-olympique.fr/2021/03/01/jutge-pascal-gauzere-a-reconnu-ses-erreurs-9401248.php
(PAYWALL)
Critiqué par les Anglais après deux décisions contestables lors de la première mi-temps face au pays de Galles, Pascal Gaüzère a fait un mea culpa auprès du patron des arbitres Joël Jutge, après avoir revisionné les images dimanche matin.
The more I think about it, the first management mistake was allowing the water carriers onto the field.
"Please go away Water Carriers, this is not a time to bring water on"
I thought the same - but the knock on was actually given against green 17- the player behind him who the ball bounced forward off as it went backwards from green 4 ( or 5) after the juggle.
That’s what I thought but that doesn’t appear to be what the referee actually said.
This thread has developed a life of its own. However, with regards to penalties (and I recognise here that you may only be talking about the time off/time on scenario), there is no need as far as I know for a referee to make a physical mark, although I agree it is very common. The mark for a penalty is simply the correct place from which the penalty should be taken. Mnny attempts at quick penalties are oly called back because the players seem unaware of the law, eg penalties to be taken on the 15m line.I tell the 9, or whoever that I’ll remake the mark and then you can go. Then whistle, arm out, maybe secondary signals and make mark - allows me to create a little breathing room if needed between whistle and mark