question :
not about the full time problem, let's say it's in normal time
if red score, and blue then commit an act of foul play, and let's say you are also going to issue YC.
What's the sequence
1 - blow whistle for try
2 - indicate try has been scored
3 - do you blow whistle again and indicate a PK ?? yes, short double/triple blow.
3a. Call over captain and culprit, tell them what your decision is
4 - issue the YC
5 - allow the conversion
6 - run to centre and make mark
7 - blow whistle and indicate PK
So as the players are returning to the dressing room, one punches another, and you would award a penalty?I have always understood that a penalty offence is penalised. Ignore hooters, for the sake of my argument.
[...]
If play continues due to a penalty offence, then it continues. There is no line to be drawn.
So as the players are returning to the dressing room, one punches another, and you would award a penalty?
Of course a line has to be drawn. The discussion is about when.
Good to have you back OB. Have you been on holiday? Supporting Spain in Brazil, perhaps?So as the players are returning to the dressing room, one punches another, and you would award a penalty?
Of course a line has to be drawn. The discussion is about when.
- a YC would be pointless ...
Sadly I had to go to America urgently for a family funeral.Good to have you back OB. Have you been on holiday? Supporting Spain in Brazil, perhaps?
The whistle usually indicates that something HAS happened. In this case it says that the game ended with the try, the conversion being specifically permitted after that.The line is the final whistle.
It has been common usage since the nineteenth century, but I have never seen any explanation. They probably thought the set "off side, on side, no side" too obvious to need explanation. Dictionaries simply define it as "the end of a rugby game"After the referee blows "no side" (etymology please, OB.. interrobang)
Given the distinction you are making, that is true whichever understanding you have of the "end of the game".the game is over and he is no longer the referee (although still a match official, of course).
The whistle usually indicates that something HAS happened. In this case it says that the game ended with the try, the conversion being specifically permitted after that.
6.A.7 (c) to (f) indicate the time when the referee MUST blow his whislte, however
[LAWS]Law 6.A.7 (b) The referee has the power to blow the whistle and stop play at any time.[/LAWS]
This covers any other times that the referee wishes to ujse his whistle to get the players' attention. This can include the short double triple whistle when he's going to the pocket. or an extra blow to indicate that a second offence has occurred.
so what would be the call if the foul play after the try happens after half time???
play would restart on half way with a PK to the non offending team????
Once again, I am amazed by some of the comments on this theme. In the event of foul or dangerous play in the act of scoring a try, a penalty must be awarded if only to emphasis that such behaviour will not be tolerated. The sequence would be - award the try, allow the conversion attempt, then speak to the captain and offending player, issue card if necessary, restart with a penalty from the half-way line, play continues normally until the ball next goes dead.
If the hooter has gone, surely, and I am guessing here, that is merely an indication to the referee that time is up. In this event, play continues as above, until the ball next goes dead.
NM
If the hooter has gone, surely, and I am guessing here, that is merely an indication to the referee that time is up. In this event, play continues as above, until the ball next goes dead.
NM
If the foul play was sufficiety bad, then the citing officer can deal with it;.